And so my personal Be Less Fat juggernaut rumbles on, with 9st 11lbs daubed along the side.* Yes: to my delight, in the past week, I've lost over two pounds! Thanks to the advice of a very kind man called Dave (@tartovski if you're on Twitter), I have changed my diet so that I'm eating little and often, rather than filling the hole in my face thrice daily, and voila! I am looking progressively less like a food-addicted hippo.
*NB I had to Photoshop a bit out of the middle of the photo as you could see my, ahem, unclad reflection - but the display is correct.
But never fear - this blog isn't going to be solely about my dwindling frame. Two weeks ago I asked you to critique the first chapter of my book; most of you were very kind, but you had a few questions, one of which was "What on earth is so wrong with James? So what if he smells like banana?"
To which I reply: James's banana smell is not the only unappealing thing about him. So below, I've posted another extract from later in the book, detailing how Anna and James met.
My question is: from this extract, (a) can you see why Anna went out with him, and (b) can you see why she might not want to be with him? (It's a tricky one, so I'd really appreciate your thoughts. Thanks in advance.)
CHAPTER 4
James and I met at Zifex, back when he worked in the IT department. I had never noticed him before he shambled up to my desk one day and asked in a strong Northern accent, “Would you like a cup of tea?”
I quickly closed down Facebook’s “Which West Wing character are YOU?” quiz, just in case he was someone with influence over my salary, and blurted, “Er, yeah, that’d be nice.”
When he returned with the tea, I decided he probably wasn’t one of the bosses, not least because he was wearing a stained black t-shirt featuring the slogan:
WHILE YOU ARE READING THIS I AM STARING AT YOUR TITS
I had always wondered what kind of person wore anti-social t-shirts. Now I’m going out with them.
“Nice t-shirt,” I said.
“Thanks,” he replied earnestly, my sarcasm whooshing over his head.
Then, just in case I might want one, he added, “I got it down Camden Market.”
After that momentous conversation, James would bring me a cup of tea each day and loiter by my desk. Over this period, he wore the t-shirts:
I’VE LOST MY VIRGINITY, CAN I HAVE YOURS?
and
YOU’RE NOT DRUNK, I REALLY AM THIS GOOD LOOKING
James isn’t bad-looking, just nondescript. He’d make a great criminal, because no one would ever be able to pick him out in an identity parade. You can picture a policeman’s spirits dropping as he took down James’s description: “The suspect was a white male, five foot nine inches tall, early thirties with brown hair and grey eyes, no distinguishing features.” Even I have trouble spotting him from a distance.
Luckily for the police force, James could never be a criminal. He doesn’t need a life of vice and subterfuge to be happy, just a cup of tea and a t-shirt emblazoned with MY BODY IS NOT A TEMPLE, IT’S AN AMUSEMENT PARK. When I first met him, I found it endearing, the way he let the world turn and didn’t ask much from it. Two and a half years on, I’m not entirely sure where that feeling went.
Soon after his tea-making courtship ritual began, James informed me that he was leaving Zifex to work at Omigron, another ISP. I remember feeling a twinge of sadness, though that could have been because he made really good tea. As I teased him about being a traitor, he asked suddenly, “Will you go out for a drink with me?”
“What, to say goodbye?” I asked, surprised.
“No,” he replied softly, “because I think you’re amazing.”
No one had ever said anything like that to me before. The idea that someone might think I was amazing was unfathomable, and also thrilling. I knew it might have been a chat-up line, but James sounded sincere, and had also gone bright red. I was 28, had been single for ages, and was lonely.
“Okay,” I agreed.
He took me to Wetherspoon’s, which admittedly isn’t the kind of place you take someone you think is amazing – I wouldn’t take Nelson Mandela there – but it was nearby, and James probably didn’t realise that it wasn’t the ideal first date venue.
As I recall, his t-shirt that day said:
THIS SHIRT WOULD LOOK GREAT ON YOUR BEDROOM FLOOR
We sat at a slightly wet table full of beer mats, and talked about work.
“Did you always want to be a computer programmer?” I asked James.
“Dunno,” he shrugged. “I always liked computers, and it came easy to me. Did you always want to work in customer services?”
I shook my head. “Advertising. I wanted to write catchy lines which stick in your head. Hopefully they’ll let me do that soon.”
James looked as doubtful as I felt.
Then he said, “I’d rather reassure people than write ‘Have a great Zifexperience’. ‘Cos that’s what you’re doing all day – being nice to people.”
I’d never thought of it that way before. And haven’t since, come to think of it. James’s lack of cynicism was refreshing, but I couldn’t quite let go of my own.
“Really, I’m trying to stop them from suing us or going elsewhere,” I pointed out. “If I had their interests at heart, I’d write, ‘Why not switch to Omigron?’”
James frowned. “But then you’d get sacked.”
I slurped my vodka and orange, and thought how ironic it was, two ISP employees having no connection. “Well, that’s why I don’t.”
We sat in awkward silence, while I briefly wondered what the shortest length of time I could stay there was. Would it be rude to leave after half an hour? Forty-five minutes? Maybe I could go to the toilet, text Lucy and get her to call me so I could use the old “my Grandma’s sick, I have to rush to her bedside” chestnut?
Then I remembered there was nothing for me to go home to, except some manky plates in the sink and an old West Wing DVD. I decided to make more of an effort.
“So is this new job the start of world domination for you?” I asked.
“Oh no no, nothing like that,” James said hastily, taking me seriously as usual and looking faintly embarrassed. “It just means working on more interesting projects. Do you want world domination then?”
No, just an interesting conversation. “I’d settle for England,” I said.
“I can’t give you that,” he replied, “but I can buy you dinner if you’d like?”
I couldn’t think of a good enough reason not to. “That would be lovely,” I answered.
And James obligingly shoved across a Wetherspoon’s menu.
*
That’s how it started. Maybe that’s how it should have ended, too, but [my best friend] Lucy was adamant I’d be making a mistake.
“You’re always telling me blokes don’t ask you out,” she pointed out, “and now one has, you’re rejecting him. Why not give him a chance?”
And so I did.
19 comments:
Hi,
Wonderful. I keep reading this with a smile on my face. Hilarious t-shirt slogans, by the way.
a) yes
b) even more so
Cheers, KJ
Yep, still like it, love the humour, but I'm beginning to wonder where we're going, I feel the need to know more, when can I buy the book?
I don't like teasers 'cause now I want to read whole book. So please keep writing.
I only hope it won't be another Bridget Jones's Diary-wannabe. ;)
Yes, I get why they went out & why she's dissatisfied now, but not how they came to live together or why it's gone on so long. He must have something more to offer?
The other section you posted was pretty good. This, however, has something not quite right with it IMHO.
The humour is still there - in fact the whole writing style is very appealing. I think the problem is that I can't empathise with the character.
When we fall for someone, our objectivity is genuinely suspended (however briefly), and we think the person is completely fantastic. Obviously that phase soon passes. But I think your character's cynicism with respect to the courtship, while amusing, is too immediate and therefore unbelievable.
Maybe you could inject more romance into the recollection of the courtship, and then dissect it afterwards in a self-deprecating style?
Maybe it's just a matter of context. Maybe the character is meant to be dysfunctional, but even so the reader needs to be tuned in to her.
I don't think there's any problem in understanding why Anna started going out with James. I think that mismatched people start dating all the time just to avoid being alone. The longer you are single, the less picky you become. Then you meet someone who is reasonably nice and without really meaning to you find yourself in a relationship that becomes a habit. You convince yourself that nobody's perfect and you should just be grateful for the things about them that are tolerable. Those with low self-esteem might assume that nobody of real worth would want them anyway. Being too fussy can leave you on the shelf, so it's a natural compromise to make do with whoever creeps within your shadow of acceptability.
YES to both of your questions. And I'd like to state again that your main character shows a lot of promise. I like that she's so broken (for lack of a better word) and pathetic (not trying to be too harsh), because it will make her journey and development throughout the novel all the more rewarding for the reader.
You know, you really are making us want to read on... so hopefully it gets published soon =)
Maybe play up the fact that when James asks the protagonist out, his display of awkward charm was quite unexpected and therefore more appealing than it would have been had he not had the appallingly poor judgment to wear those T-shirts (to work, no less).
I don't want to sound ilke one of James' T-shirts, but if the new photograph of you is recent, then you ought not invest too much anxiety in the weight loss project -- your figure caught and held my eye.
This was funny! As to questions a and b: it reminded me of someone I know who was going out with a guy for a few years. Although he wasn't perfectly nice, it was obvious he was nowhere near as smart and funny as she was. It looked like laziness on her part, and she finally realised that she was coasting and has, I'm happy to say, found someone who's probably harder work, but who is more rewarding. (Reader, she married him.)
Oh bugger. I wish I could edit my comment. He was perfectly nice.
Thanks for all your lovely comments, and apologies for the massive delay. It's all been a bit crazy in London for the past two days - the supermarkets near us have boarded up early and there are riot police two streets away. Luckily we're away from the action, but it's quite scary nonetheless.
@KJ: Thank you, but I have a confession to make: those are all t-shirts I've seen in real life - I didn't make up the slogans (unfortunately!) A few weeks ago I saw a portly bald bloke wearing a t-shirt saying "Sex instructor - first lesson free". I was a bit taken aback, but when I told my boyfriend about it, he said that t-shirt slogan had been around since the 1980s!
@PeteKnight: Sadly you can't buy the book until I've written the rest of it and sold it to a publisher, but I'm very pleased that you want to.
@buttie: Thank you - I'll try to keep writing. And no more teasers, I promise.
@Anonymous: Well, he's quite kind, and gentle, and he thinks she's wonderful, so that's flattering. Not sure he can have that much to offer though, otherwise she'd want to be with him, and that would spoil the plot! I think it's dragged on for so long because she hasn't had any other offers and doesn't want to be alone.
@Anonymous 2: Thanks for your honesty. I actually based Anna's experience on my own experience of going out with a man I wasn't really into (he smelt of banana, hence the first chapter - though fortunately he didn't wear slogan t-shirts). I genuinely never fell for him, though I kept hoping I would. So, erm, maybe that makes me dysfunctional! Sorry you couldn't identify with her, but maybe that's a good thing as far as your own love life is concerned...?!
@Graham: That's exactly what I meant to convey - James is reasonably nice, and she's been single for ages, so she thinks: why not give it a go? When it turns out to be a mistake, she still finds ways to convince herself that she's better off with him than on her own.
@Alessa: Glad you like Anna. She definitely ends the novel a different person to the one she is in the beginning (not that I've written it yet!)
@TransplantedLawyer: Yes, that's a good idea. And you're very kind, but I'm afraid that photo was taken before I was pregnant. I decided to put some photos up of myself looking slim, in the hope that they'll inspire me on my weight loss quest!
@Brian: Glad you liked it. It's good that your friend found someone she was better matched with - I've seen so many mismatched couples where other people are secretly humming "Is she really going out with him?" (or vice-versa).
Another way to lose weight is to eat smaller meals than normal and to skip dinner altogeather or to have something very light, like a soup or toast rather than a full meal until you get used to not eating dinner (can be difficult to get used to initially). If you eat many small meals a day, you are constantly starting and stopping and thus straing the digestive system, which must not be good in the long run (remembering that it all works with stomach acid). Basically in a nutshell food is energy or fuel for the body, only consume what you need. Based on the words of the Buddha see http://www.accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/mn/mn.070.than.html
Eugh! Those t-shirts. That brings back horrible memories of my last attempt at clothes shopping a few months back:
http://ben-park.co.uk/2011/01/30/a-dedicated-avoider-of-fashion
I know exactly why she went out with him.
I'd mostly agree with Graham.
She was lonely/bored/whatever, and someone paid her some attention.
And she's stayed with him because it's an easy routine to fall into, and he's not really so bad.
My only criticism of this new section is that it seems rather dated, with The West Wing being mentioned. There's probably a current big quiz on Facebook, that it could easily be replaced with.
On the other hand, it's a classic (apparently - I never watched it).
Sadly, those sort of t-shirts are still widely available.
I like your writing very much, and I can answer yes to both questions.
My take on it is that James not only is perfectly nice, perfectly safe and perfectly uninteresting, but he is totally missing any clue whatsoever.
So when she starts dating him, because she has nothing better on hand, he suggests moving in, with as much grace as he exhibited in this chapter.
Yes to (a) and (b). She wanted to be with him because his affection validated her, but now she's realised that it's so secure and monotonous that's it's no longer fulfilling and she needs a new challenge. He's just like a big, dumb labrador. A big, dumb labrador that smells of bananas.
@R. K. Wijayaratne: Thanks for the tip. Not sure I can skip dinner altogether though - my stomach is gnawing at itself all night as it is!
@BenPark: "It looks like the sort of password your bank insist you set up" made me laugh! Good point about the West Wing - will change that.
@skongstad: Very pleased you liked it. Yes, that's how I envisioned it - he just wore her down and there was nobody better around, so (much like in this extract) she thought 'Why not?'
@BenSix: That's it exactly. Though I'd quite like a big dumb labrador...
From chapter 1 we know James is into football. That's often unpleasant.
So is my boyfriend (into football, not unpleasant). I think most blokes are.
A lot of blokes are into football to the point of being obsessed by it, which is what I think your character is supposed to be (am I right?). When they are, it's often unpleasant, or at least when they neglect the rest.
Or maybe I never really got into football.
Post a Comment